Get This Blog by Email
BlogAboutBlogOverclockedResearchInitiativesPhotos
« Reweighting Newsweek’s ‘08 Poll SNL on Hillary »


Handicapping Obama vs. Hillary

by Patrick Ruffini :: January 21st, 2007 6:31 pm

It’s rare that I find something on HuffPo worth linking to, but Steve Rosenbaum’s take on Obama vs. Hillary’s video e-announcements is totally on point. Rosenbaum is the director of the long tail documentary on Kerry’s campaign “Inside the Bubble” that I would totally buy if he released it on DVD already.

Simply put - Obama’s words feel like his own. Both convincing and colloquial. Direct and spoken without any sense that he’s being asked to read ‘copy’. His delivery is authentic. In stark contrast, Hillary is struggling with words that are not her own. You can practically see the tele-prompter reflected in her eyes. Every word has been word smithed, every phrase looked at by a team of consultants. Even the subject line of the email - “I’m in. And I’m in to win”- seems to respond to some unspoken marketing concern about her candidacy. Clinton’s video is directed to look ‘casual’ , with the camera panning gently back and forth (like those old Maxwell House commercials). In contrast - Obama’s spot doesn’t attempt any false causal film effects… counting instead on his ability to deliver his message direct to camera. Don’t get me wrong, there a moments were Clinton is clearly speaking her mind, when she says with a bit of exasperation - “after Six Years of George Bush…it is time to renew the promise of America.” But when she then says - “Let’s talk, lets chat…” you can just see the speech writers trying to find a way to soften her with the word ‘chat’. Please. Hillary Clinton doesn’t ‘chat’ - and it’s not credible coming out of her mouth. “Because the conversation in Washington has been a little one sided - don’t ‘ca think.” I do, but I don’t by Hillary talking in slang. Obama instead is almost flat - straight - not overselling or over-promising. Just laying out his plans, with a frankness that’s refreshing.

Don’t put me down as a big Obama fan, but with candidates spending more time speaking direct to camera in 2008, authenticity will count for more and more and the ability to speak in pre-packaged soundbites will matter less and less.

Via The Wire.

UPDATE: And the prize for least compelling video announcement goes to… Bill Richardson.

Tagged:

Comments Comments (2) Comments Trackbacks (0) del.icio.us digg it subscribe

This was posted in: Uncategorized

Both comments and pings are currently closed.

  1. Banjo says:

    Obama gives good speech. Just about any actor could be taught to deliver lines as sincerely. The question is what’s the guy actually done apart from voting to the left of Kennedy?

    # January 22nd, 2007 at 11:25 am

  2. Carl says:

    Hillary has been the most scripted senator. Her entire campaigns for NY senator were heavily controlled. No interviews unless they had pre-approved questions given to the host or were done by a host heavily sympathetic to her. Either way, no hard questions (just like the softballs tossed to her during the interviews on ABC, CBS and NBC on Monday). Back when she was co-president she used the secret service to keep the press away from her and I can recall only one press interview she granted during that time. Even having her announcement being on the web keeps questions being asked of her. She’s known as a cold, hardened socialist in Washington circles and supposedly unnamed democrat staffers have admitted off the record that hardly anyone in congress on either side of the aisle likes her. Since she’s finally announced she’s running, it is expected she’ll have an image consultant team devoted to reshaping her persona to appear to be more caring. I’m just not going to buy it. However I know there will be plenty of gullible liberals who’ll accept it; hook, line and sinker. In that case, P.T. Barnum was wrong…it’s more like ever 15 seconds.

    # January 23rd, 2007 at 12:41 am

Patrick Ruffini   Patrick Ruffini is an online political strategist, blogger, and wearer of many hats. More...


Ruffini Around the Web







 Subscribe in a reader

Add to Google

Subscribe in NewsGator Online

Subscribe in Bloglines

Add to My AOL

Subscribe in Rojo




Tags
2008 actblue activism al gore announcements barack obama bill clinton blogosphere bush congress conservatism cpac debate democrats epolitics eric cantor facebook fred thompson fundraising grassroots hillary clinton iowa iraq jim ogonowski john edwards john mccain MA 5 marketing media mike huckabee mitt romney movement netroots new hampshire online politics overclocked polls rightroots ron paul ronald reagan rudy giuliani savethedebate south carolina strategy straw poll technology user generated content video web2.0 youtube

By Month

  • May 2008
  • April 2008
  • March 2008
  • February 2008
  • January 2008
  • December 2007
  • November 2007
  • October 2007
  • September 2007
  • August 2007
  • July 2007
  • June 2007
  • May 2007
  • April 2007
  • March 2007
  • February 2007
  • January 2007
  • December 2006



  •   


  • Blogroll

  • Join the email list
    Blogs
    Main
    Overclocked
    On the Side

    About
    Bio
    Portfolio
    2008 Wire
    MSM, Blogs
    GOP, Dems
    FAQ
    Initiatives
    ECorps
    Research
    Photo Gallery

    © 2007 Ruffini Strategies LLC

    Clicky Web Analytics